Community Reviews
C
this review : https://goodreads.com/review/show/63159873?book_show_action=true&page=1
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
A
this review : https://goodreads.com/review/show/63159873?book_show_action=true&page=1
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
P
this review : https://goodreads.com/review/show/63159873?book_show_action=true&page=1
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
this review : https://goodreads.com/review/show/63159873?book_show_action=true&page=1
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
I wouldn't give it two stars as this reviewer did but I pretty much agree.
The main thing I remember about this book is that Sawyer introduces truly alien aliens then as he usually does makes them pretty much human. Good concept: the aliens believe that because their god is Omniscient and omnipotent , anything they do must be OK because otherwise wouldn't god have stopped them? I like the reasoning but as a matter of practicality how can a society function like that? That reasoning should lead to atheism.
The other thing I remember is that one of the aliens cut off someone's legs (human) because they didn't understand human anatomy and meant it to only be incapacitating not lethal. That was a defense i guess.
See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.